Gluten-Free Valentine Sugar Cookies

By · Print This Post Print This Post


Time for the Valentine parties at school. What will you be contributing? For our parties, we’ll be taking gluten-free candy hearts and gluten-free sugar cookies to share with classmates.

The candy hearts were a lot more work than I had anticipated. I encountered some confusion with the allergy statements on the Brach’s and Necco’s Conversation Hearts, so I decided to go with SweetTarts Hearts this year. Wonka SweetTarts Hearts were the only candy hearts I could find made by a company that says their candy is gluten-free and has labeling on the candy packaging that consistently indicated it was gluten-free. The kids love the candy and it’s heart-shaped, so all is good!

For my son’s class, I signed up for the sugar cookies. I always try to sign up to bring something that is not usually gluten-free, because I know I will be bringing a gluten-free version for my kids to have with their classmates anyway. (In addition to the treats we signed up to bring, I will also be bringing gluten-free cupcakes, pretzels and sandwiches for my kids so they can eat the same foods along with their classmates.)

Here’s my Sugar Cookie Recipe:


3/4 Cup unsalted butter
1 Cup sugar
1 large egg
1 TBSP vanilla extract (Make sure it’s gluten-free! We use McCormick’s brand.)
1 Cup Brown Rice Flour (Superfinely ground is best for texture. We buy Authentic Foods brand.)
1/2 Cup Potato Starch (not potato flour)
1/4 Cup Tapioca Flour
1/4 Cup Sweet Sorghum Flour (Or use Sweet Rice Flour.)
1 tsp baking powder
1 tsp xanthan gum
1/4 tsp salt

  1. Beat butter and sugar in a large bowl with mixer until light and creamy. Add egg and vanilla and mix until smooth.
  2. Add flours, baking powder, xanthan gum, and salt. Beat until a thick smooth dough is formed.
  3. img_29841Place the dough on plastic wrap and divide into two pieces. Then flatten each piece into a round and wrap in plastic wrap. Place them in the refrigerator to chill until very cold (30 – 60 min.).
  4. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Position rack in center of oven. Place parchment paper on cookie sheet or lightly grease cookie sheet.
  5. Once the dough is chilled, unwrap it and place on parchment paper (wax paper and plastic wrap works, too). Place plastic wrap on top and roll it out until it’s about 1/4-inch thick. Then remove the plastic wrap and cut into desired shapes using cookie cutters. Place the cookies on a prepared cookie sheet. If using decorative sugar, sprinkle it on the cookies before baking.
  6. img_2988Place the cookie sheet in the oven and cook for 10-12 minutes or until lightly golden. Transfer to a wire rack for cooling.
  7. Spread icing on cookies if desired.* Store in an airtight container. Recipe makes about 4 dozen cookies.

* For cookie icing, I simply mix powdered sugar with a small amount of water and desired food coloring. Adjust the water and sugar to get a preferred consistency: not too runny that it runs off the cookie, but thin enough to spread easily. Try starting with a cup of powdered sugar and a couple tablespoons of water. Once you’ve put the icing on the cookies, give it a few hours to dry and harden before putting into the airtight containers.

This recipe was modified and inspired by Annalise Roberts’s recipe in

Categories : Desserts, Holidays, Parenting



Internet friend of Char’s…LOVE the new site. My son is Gluten/Casein free due to H Pylori exposure as a baby. I have trouble finding good baking/dinner ideas for him and the entire family so this will be a great resource for me. THANK YOU!
I will also pass this on to my autism friends. 🙂


Thank you for your good words. I’m glad you like the site. I hope you and your friends continue to find it helpful, as I add more to it. Thanks!


[…] Gluten-Free Sugar Cookie Recipe from scratch makes about 4 dozen cookies, so you should only need to make one batch. Categories […]


[…] of Celiac Family is on mommy duty like Nicola!  Valentine’s sugar cookies, heart shaped brownies…and she even made a heart shaped pizza, too.  She has a pictoral menu […]


[…] Sugar Cookies are always a favorite treat for Halloween. These were made using my favorite sugar cookie recipe, some orange frosting, and a little green-colored sugar for the […]


[…] Tree Meringue Cookies we made last week, we’ll bake and decorate some traditional sugar cookies to munch on and share this week. Boy, I am really going to have to join up with […]


i am new to this site…and so far i love it however, last week i came across a recipe for ginger spice cookies on a page that had many different cookie recipes and the submitters picture was next to it…i cannot seem to navigate back to that page…the cookies were AMAZING and now i can’t find them…help!


Robyn, You must have seen those at the Gluten-Free Menu Swap. Last week’s theme was Holiday Treats and I believe you’ll find the picture of the Gingersnap Cookies in the roundup at Angela’s Kitchen (http://angelaskitchen.com/2011/12/05/menu-plan-monday-december-5-2011/). Hope that helps!


Wonderful recipe! I substituted 1/4cup coconut flour for rice flour and they turned out great. Thank you for the recipe!


Shawn – I love the idea of using coconut flour! Thanks for sharing your success. I’m going to try it next time.


I am not really a fan of Sorghum but am looking for a good Sugar Cookie recipe that holds it shape and wont cause Gluten eaters to spit it out! LOL. Do you think I’ll like these with the Sorghum?


Lisa – I don’t notice the taste of sorghum in these, as it only calls for 1/4 cup. But, if you are sensitive to the taste, I suggest using sweet rice flour instead. I think the sweet rice flour may be a little better at helping it hold together better, too.


[…] month I made snicker doodles by using this sugar cookie recipe and rolling the dough into balls, then rolling in cinnamon sugar, and slightly flattening with […]


[…] Get Heather’s Valentine Sugar Cookies recipe over at Celiac Family. […]


[…] Sugar Cookie – recipe to cutout holiday shapes and frost […]


[…] week, I’m making gluten-free/dairy-free/nut-free Heart-shaped Sugar Cookies for school celebrations. I’m also making Meringue Heart Cookies and Dairy-free Creme […]


[…] Valentine Sugar Cookies from Celiac Family ~ gluten free, […]


[…] Sugar Cookie Recipe for cut-out shapes (GF) @CeliacFamily […]

Leave a Comment